Advantages And Disadvantages Of Analytic And Holistic Rubrics
To write a document, we will have to give
some headings. The name of a heading on a document is known as a rubric. There are different types of rubrics
but the most important ones are analytic and holistic rubrics. The holistic
rubric is also known as single dimensional rubric whereas the analytic rubric
is known as a two-dimensional rubric. In
holistic rubric, all the descriptions are written in paragraphs and full
sentences. On the other hand, in the analytic
rubric, all the descriptions are written in a table form. If you don’t have
enough idea about analytic and holistic rubrics, then you can get help from dissertation
writing services.
Advantages
of Holistic Rubrics:
The most
general kind of the rubric is known as a holistic
rubric. There involves three to five level of performance in holistic rubrics.
There are a lot of advantages of the holistic
rubric. Some of them are given below;
- The students can easily score with the help of holistic rubric. That’s why it is also known as a quick scoring rubric. With the help of quick scoring, it can provide a quick overview of the achievement of the students.
- It is easy for students to obtain a single dimension with the help of holistic rubric.
- With the help of holistic rubric, it is also easy for the teachers to provide full detail of the criteria.
- If you want to get some effective feedback from your instructor, then this rubric is also helpful to you.
Disadvantages
of a Holistic Rubric:
Along with
advantages of the holistic rubric, there
are also some disadvantages of the holistic
rubric. These disadvantages are given below;
- In order to provide full instructions, a detailed plan of the weaknesses and strengths of a particular product is required. The holistic rubric fails to provide this plan.
- With the help of holistic rubric, we can’t provide detailed information about a product.
- This kind of rubric can also become a cause of restricting the mind power of the students.
Advantages
of an Analytic Rubric:
The main
purpose of an analytic rubric is to access the different skills of a student.
Some advantages of the analytic rubrics are given below;
- With the help of analytic rubric, it is easy for a teacher to provide meaningful feedback to the students on the basis of different dimensions.
- The students can create a consistency between the scores and grades.
- With the help of analytic rubric, it is also easy for a teacher to share the weaknesses and strengths of the students with their parents.
- An analytic rubric can also reflect the quality of the work.
Disadvantages
of Analytic Rubrics
Like
holistic rubric, there are also some disadvantages of the analytic rubric. These disadvantages are given
below;
- It is difficult for the students to construct an analytic rubric for all of their academic tasks.
- There requires a huge amount of time to construct an analytic rubric.
If we talk about the consistency of the
different raters, then we come to know that there is a lower consistency.